I started off thinking...how ridiculous. Make my own detergent?!?
And then I remembered that I love doing ridiculous, overly complicated,
messy projects (Chestnut Soup from scratch, anyone?). I especially love
when I tell people about these projects and they stare wide eyed at me
in shock and horror. They never ask me to watch their kids, so I am
going to call that a win.
So
when I first saw the blog on how to make this liquid detergent...I
saved it on my Pinterest board, and moved on. After we had polished off
two giant (Costco sized) containers of detergent and one gallon milk
jug...I ran over to Oliver's for some supplies. I provided ingredient images, and you can click on the images to go to the product web page. (It will open in another tab). The
wonderwoman from whom I got this recipe has some excellent photos of the process that you can see by clicking the above link. I doubled the recipe and added orange essential oil. You can see my version, my thoughts and the full cost break--down following the images.
Recipe:
Feel free to halve it
Courtesy of
Why Not Sew (please look there for her great step by step pictures, but know that I changed the recipe a tad.)
Items:
2 cups of Borax
2 cups of Washing Soda
1 Bar of Fels Naptha
(a couple drops of essential oil)
a huge pot ( I use my canning pot because it only holds closed jars...not food.)
a grater
a funnel
a long spoon
5 empty gallon jugs
1. Grate your soap into your pot.
2. Add one gallon of water to pot and heat.
3. Cook until soap dissolves. (less than 10 minutes)
4. Add borax and washing soda.
5. Bring to a boil (it will thicken)
6. Turn off heat and stir well
7. Add two more gallons of cold water. Let cool.
8. Using the funnel, pour into the jugs. (Enjoy the smell of your kitchen!)
It will coagulate more and more as it cools. When we use our detergent it comes out in plops... and the initial load forced us to squeeze the tub a tiny bit. It works very well even though it doesn't behave exactly like store bought detergent. It also seems to sometimes be randomly thicker. This is STRONG detergent and benefits from more dilution if you are up to it.
Cost Break--down
Essential Oil: $5.89 for .25 fluid ounces
20 Mule Team Borax: $4.29 for 76 oz (On-Line, I paid $2.80 in store)
Arm & Hammer Washing Soda: $2.50 for 55 oz
Fels Naptha: $2.19 for 5.5 oz bar.
I got all these prices today and on-line. I spent less by buying at a locally owned store. I also had previously purchased the orange oil, and used only a few drops. Here is what the total cost for my loads of laundry.
Total without oil: $8.89
With Oil: $14.87
Taxes not included...I will be as specific as possible, but I have no idea what local taxes you may be working with and if you buy on-line...well, that's another story entirely.
What I used for my recipe:
2 cups each of borax and washing soda = 16 oz of each product.
For Borax, it costs less than 6 cents for each ounce so...
(.056 x 16 ounces) 16 ounces of Borax = 90 cents.
You then have 60 oz remaining of Borax, which will yield 3.75 more attempts at the recipe (that is doubled).
Washing soda cost less than 5 cents an ounce so...
(.045 x 16 ounces) 16 ounces of Borax = 72 cents
You then have enough for 3.3* more attempts at the doubled recipe.
Fels Naptha: I used one bar for this recipe because it is a very strong soap cleaning soap.
$2.19 for one recipe.
Total recipe cost (excluding the estimate for oil because I used less than one ounce, and I am not even going to attempt that math!!)
$3.81
How much did we make?
This much. Yikes!
The big guys are 210 ounces each. A gallon is 128 ounces, but let's round down because our jug wasn't completely full. Let's say we made 540 ounces of detergent. Assuming you use 1/2 cup (or about 4 ounces) of detergent you made 135 loads.
Cost Per Load: .028 or 3 cents a load.
But this assumes you need a heavy dose of detergent. The detergent boxes that we bought say they contain enough for 105 standard loads. If we do it their way, at 2 ounces a load:
270 loads of laundry at .014 cents a load. That's less than 2 cents a load, people!
For fun, let's go back and look at how much this product cost us and total up how much it would cost to make it three more times.
If you buy three more bars it will cost you a little less than $16 dollars to make detergent that will wash somewhere between: 540 and 1080 loads of laundry. And you still have some borax and washing soda to use for other cleaning projects.
We bought the ECO costco brand detergent for about $14 dollars a jug. This cut the price to less than half. But that's not all...
Noticeable Benefits to making your own detergent
1) Clothes smell great. (they smell faintly of orange and do not have that cheap laundry mat detergent smell--I was sort of concerned about this--not sure I should own up to that.)
2) Clothing is much softer. We have don't use fabric softener and have since stopped using dryer sheets. (Which saves more!) Even my husband has noticed the difference.
3) Clothes are getting as clean as they were before. I successfully washed bloody nose damage out of sheets...without bleach people.
4) No Suds (Which I hear is good for HE washers, not that we have one).
My Take: I love it. The recipe was stupid easy to make. I'm actually embarrassed it took me so long to try it. So there. Try it. Love it. Pass it on.
*Did you note the difference between the two washing detergents? So say you use this recipe three more times and have left overs of both soda and borax. Great news. The cleaning agents can be used in almost everything. (I recently sprinkled some borax on a wet bed...it took up all of the odor and most of the moisture.)